QuickTake:

An amended motion calls for a public meeting to discuss shuttering a pair of degree programs. Faculty members vowed to make the cases for preserving the programs.

The Lane Community College Board of Education tossed a potential lifeline to a pair of LCC programs that college administrators have targeted for closure. 

During a meeting Tuesday, March 31, members voted to support a “mitigation plan” designed to trim more than $9 million during the next three school years from LCC’s general fund. That plan calls for making $4.2 million of those cuts from next year’s budget and includes closing the college’s degree programs in criminal justice and health information management.

But the motion attracted an amendment from board member Zachary Mulholland calling for the board to formally vote on closing the two programs at a later meeting, “after a public presentation about the programs and an opportunity for public comment.”

The debate over the amendment, which passed on a 4-3 vote, was the latest flare-up of an issue that has divided board members during the past year: To what extent should they focus primarily on overall governance issues versus how deeply should they delve into operations?

More specifically, the Tuesday discussion focused on this question: Should the board be able to vote to approve or shutter academic programs?

“That should be a board decision,” Mulholland said. “That’s been a board decision for a long time, and I don’t know when that changed or who changed it, but I want to go back to that longstanding practice of the board voting on program closures.”

Board member Julie Weismann disagreed.

“The moment this board assumes authority over academic programming decisions, we are no longer governing,” she said. “We are administering. And we are doing so without academic expertise or the accreditation authority to do so.”

Mulholland, Chair Austin Fölnagy, Vice Chair Jerry Rust and Jesse Maldonado voted in favor of the amendment. (Maldonado has emerged as a key swing vote on the seven-member board.) 

Weismann, Steve Mital and Kevin Alltucker voted against the amendment.

The board later approved the full amended motion on a 5-2 vote, with Mital switching his vote to “yes.” Mital said he “very much preferred” the original motion to the amended version, but said the amended motion at least “keeps a very difficult process moving forward, which is important. That’s what I supported.”

But he warned the amended motion could make identifying the remaining cutbacks “more political and less rational.” 

Three-year plan

The proposed cuts to the two academic programs are part of an overall $9.2 million three-year plan to return LCC’s ending fund balance — essentially, its reserves — to a level equal to 10% of its general fund, as required by board policy. LCC’s general fund is about $108 million, and its projected ending fund balance for this school year is about 7.45%.

Without the cutbacks, LCC officials say the college would continue to spend more than it takes in and its ending fund balance would drop to 5.03% by the end of the 2029 school year. The idea is to cut about $4.2 million from the 2026-27 budget and follow up with an additional $2.5 million in cuts each of the two following school years. 

Details of the first $4.2 million in cuts were presented to the board at its March 18 work session in Florence. 

They include a net reduction of 20.5 full-time equivalent positions. In total, about $2.2 million would be trimmed from operations and about $1 million from support services.

But most of the nearly 75 minutes of public comments at Tuesday’s meeting focused on the proposed $982,850 in cuts from academic programs, with about $534,000 of that coming from closing the criminal justice and health information management degree programs. LCC administrators said the programs both have had relatively low enrollment and completion rates.

Coordinators of the programs, students, leaders of LCC’s two main unions and others pushed back Tuesday against the planned closures.

Rick Riordan, the coordinator of LCC’s Health Information Management program, said he was hoping the board would vote Tuesday to retain the program.

“We didn’t get that, but they didn’t vote to suspend it,” he said Wednesday. “So I’m encouraged about that, and now we’ve got to go through the process and continue to make the case.”

He said the program has a strong case to make. He told the board that the program is “growing, financially viable and aligned with documented workforce needs.” He contested claims that artificial intelligence would eliminate jobs in the field. 

The coordinator of the criminal justice program, Caoimhin O’Fearghail, said in an email to Lookout Eugene-Springfield that cutting the program would actually reduce revenue to the college. 

“The program serves a variety of student populations on campus, and the degree more broadly serves the community by providing an opportunity for students interested in careers in public service while contributing to the development of a more knowledgeable, empathetic, and competent workforce,” O’Fearghail said.

He said the board’s vote on the amendment was “an important first step. It will now be important for the board to seek input from students, employers, partner institutions and the public rather than to rely solely on information provided by the administration, which is proposing cuts.”

Students also criticized how college administrators communicated the news about the cuts.

“The future I thought I was building is being taken away,” said a student who said she was planning to apply for the Health Information Management program.

Other cuts and next steps

Other students questioned plans to close LCC’s Printing and Graphics department, which would force the outsourcing of many of the college’s printing needs. Students also opposed cutbacks in its course-embedded tutor program.

Tami Hill, president of the Lane Community College Employee Federation — the union representing LCC classified members — said the board’s vote on the amended motion “just closed” Printing and Graphics. LCC officials said administrators are “working to preserve some functionalities that will support student academic needs, such as specialized printing services, lab opportunities for students and other educational-related resources.”

But it was not immediately clear if the board’s action Tuesday also applied to cuts beyond the proposed closure of the two academic programs.

The motion specifies that the board should vote on closing the two academic programs. But it doesn’t mention the additional $3.7 million in cuts outlined in the mitigation plan. LCC administrators said the language of the motion suggests the board has approved those cuts.

Nevertheless, Fölnagy seemed to leave the door open for wider review of the cuts in a Wednesday email sent to Lookout: 

“We heard from students’ alumni’s voices in public comment speaking to the value of various programs to the community and their own lived experiences,” he said, adding that these are important stakeholders.

It also was unclear Wednesday when the public meeting and vote called for in the board’s motion would be held. Fölnagy said scheduling details could be worked out this week in an agenda-setting meeting he and Rust will hold with LCC President Stephanie Bulger. 

LCC administrators had hoped the board would approve the mitigation plan — without any amendment — at Tuesday’s meeting, saying such approval would allow them to prepare for meetings with LCC’s Budget Committee, which is scheduled to start work April 22. LCC must have a finished budget ready by July, the start of the fiscal year. The full board has only two regular meetings remaining this school year, May 6 and June 3, with a work session scheduled May 20.

Fölnagy downplayed those concerns, saying that LCC’s budget process usually starts in May. “So this would fall in line with traditional processes of the budget timeline, which is finalized in June,” he said.

New student member

Tuesday’s meeting was the first for the board’s new student member, Michael Olson, the new president of the Lane LCC Student Government Association. 

The student representative does not get a vote on the board, but Olson made his presence known, questioning administrators about how much student input was solicited on the mitigation plan. He also successfully asked that the board discussion of the plan be moved forward on the agenda so it didn’t occur late in the meeting, which lasted 4 hours and 8 minutes, including an 11-minute break.

Mike McInally is a Pacific Northwest journalist with four decades of experience in Oregon and Montana, including stints as editor of the Corvallis Gazette-Times and the Albany Democrat-Herald.