QuickTake:
The federal court ruling is a win for protesters seeking to prove their claims that police actions, such as barricading a street, infringed on their rights to free speech during a racially influenced 2020 march.
Springfield police lack immunity from claims that officers violated the free speech and other rights of protesters during a 2020 march, U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken ruled Friday, Jan. 23.
A lawsuit filed by an organizer of the march, Black Unity, and five people attending the street demonstration alleges civil rights violations by the city and several individual Springfield police officers, including Richard Lewis, the city’s police chief at the time.
The July 29, 2020 march took place at a time of nationwide street protests against racism and police brutality. But the march “aimed mainly to protest a noose that had been hung from a tree in a yard on Bluebelle Way in Springfield’s Thurston Hills neighborhood, a house located across the street from a Black neighbor,” Aiken wrote.
The march took place about two months after the death of George Floyd, a Black man who was handcuffed and lying facedown on a Minneapolis street when a white police officer put his knee against Floyd’s neck for several minutes. The officer was later found guilty of murder and manslaughter.
The legal claims by the Springfield protesters remain as yet unproven, but Aiken’s ruling denies motions filed by the city of Springfield and by individual officers seeking summary judgment in their favor.
Much of Aiken’s ruling discusses the decision by Springfield police to erect barricades as a way to direct the march. Event organizers were not told there would be a barricade, and Aiken wrote that police “blocked access to more than half of the Thurston Hills neighborhood, which was the marchers’ intended audience.”
In court documents, police had argued that they should be shielded from the claims because of “qualified immunity.” The legal concept generally protects government officials, including police, from civil damages unless their conduct violates clearly established rights.
But Aiken disagreed.
“Given the long-standing precedent on prior restraints of street marches, a reasonable officer would have known that blockading a street march in advance of actual expression without lawful process or sufficient justification would violate the First Amendment,” Aiken wrote.
Aiken also referred to skirmishes involving protesters, police and counterprotesters.
A city spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment, and an attorney with the Civil Liberties Defense Center, which is representing the protesters, noted the length of Aiken’s opinion.
“Unfortunately we will not be able to get through the 120-page opinion before close of business today,” attorney Marianne Dugan said in an email, declining comment until Monday.
Regarding free-speech claims by protesters, Aiken wrote that the legal question about the police barricade “is whether the barricade was in fact an unlawful prior restraint on First Amendment activity or whether it was a reasonable time, place, and manner restriction.”
Springfield police had said in court filings that they placed a barricade at the intersection of 67th and Dogwood streets “to prevent the marchers from continuing along 67th Street to Main Street, a busy five-lane road with a 45-mph speed limit that ‘has experienced numerous vehicle-versus-pedestrian crashes resulting in fatalities,’” Aiken wrote.
But Aiken noted that protesters, in their legal arguments, had said police set up the barricade two blocks from Main Street.
Another legal argument made by protesters was that the police actions were not “content neutral” because the barricade was not enforced against counterprotesters.
“The video evidence shows that, unlike the marchers, counter protesters were permitted to speak and assemble on both sides of the barrier,” Aiken wrote. “The evidence shows counter protesters filming from the police side of the barrier and even cheering on the officers.”
Aiken ruled that a “reasonable jury could find that the barricade was enforced only against the marchers, but not the counter protesters, because of the content of the marchers’ speech.”
Aiken also said that there were “disputes of material fact as to whether that restriction was ‘narrowly tailored’ to serve the stated public safety goal.”
Excessive force, other claims
The ruling allowed excessive force claims against police to move forward after some Black Unity marchers sustained injuries as officers arrested a marcher and pushed back against others.
Aiken said videos failed to show evidence of violence or crowd incitement by marchers before police force was used.
“The video footage shows no evidence that the crowd was threatening the officers or intending to charge the barricades,” Aiken wrote.
Tyshawn Ford, one of the marchers alleging excessive force, did cross the barricade and taunted or insulted police, Aiken said.
The ruling states that, earlier, “video footage shows that Ford invited the crowd, whoever ‘is willing,’ to continue the march with him through the barricade.” But Aiken wrote the video also showed Ford telling the crowd, “‘We gotta stay strong. We gotta stay nonviolent.’”
“The footage shows no evidence that Ford’s words were either directed to inciting or
likely to incite the crowd. Ford is calm, and the crowd is calm; there is no evidence
of violence or physical disorder in the nature of a riot,” Aiken wrote.
The lawsuit claims Ford was held down and repeatedly punched in his head and face by Springfield police officers as he was placed under arrest.
The judge’s ruling notes that Ford pleaded no contest to a misdemeanor disorderly conduct charge, which was dismissed after he completed a diversion agreement. Another marcher later charged with assault ultimately had charges dismissed, the ruling states.
Aiken also allowed due process claims in the lawsuit to move forward. The ruling notes several instances where police gathered information about marchers and states that police “offer no evidence that they collected protesters’ data because of permit status, crowd size, or any disorderly conduct.”
In allowing the claims to move forward, Aiken also wrote that evidence “viewed in the light most favorable” to those suing Springfield police suggests “that the SPD data gathering project was not limited to the July 29 march but instead was part of a larger ongoing project.”
In court documents, Springfield police argued that none of their actions had anything to do with the viewpoint of protesters, but Aiken wrote that police “fail to explain the evidence that suggests that they treated counter protesters favorably and to the marchers’ detriment.”
The judge wrote there exists at least some evidence police “enforced the barricade only against the marchers but not against the counter protesters.” Noting the re-routing of the march, which had been planned to start and end at Jesse Main Park, Aiken also wrote that there was some evidence that police “forced the marchers to re-route via Dogwood Street — the only route back to the park — where Defendants knew that hostile and armed counter protesters waited.”
Aiken wrote that there are “genuine issues of material fact as to whether Defendants knowingly neglected or declined to prevent racially motivated violence from being inflicted on Plaintiffs by counter protesters.”
The ruling allows claims to move forward by protesters that Springfield police “conspired to deprive them of equal protection of the laws on the basis of race.”

