QuickTake:
On a 6-2 vote, the City Council directed City Manager Jenny Haruyama to return by February with a plan that would allow the city to “make incremental progress” toward a Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act program.
The city of Eugene will advance a Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act policy — slowly.
Six of eight Eugene city councilors on Monday, Nov. 16, voted to direct City Manager Jenny Haruyama to share a work plan by February that would allow the city to “make incremental progress over time” toward a TOPA program.
Broadly speaking, the policy would give renters the first right of refusal on buying their home before it goes on the market.
The requested work plan will include a timeline, a “detailed prioritized list” of tasks to advance TOPA and their financial impacts.
Haruyama recommended the council table the TOPA proposal altogether last week, but a majority of councilors pushed back on the advice. Some councilors opted to continue exploring a TOPA policy bit-by-bit.
Due to Eugene’s budget shortfall, some councilors on Monday said they want to pursue regulatory changes that would give tenants prior notice of a building sale before funding a larger program to help renters buy property through direct financial assistance and education.
“Even if that just lets one or two more people take advantage of this opportunity, removing that one barrier is valuable,” Councilor Eliza Kashinsky said.

Councilor Mike Clark and Randy Groves rejected the motion, arguing there were better uses for the funds.
“The problem is, can people come up with a down payment? Can people qualify for a home loan? Those are the barriers, and we really aren’t talking about that,” Groves said.
Some councilors who voted in favor of the motion, like Councilor Jennifer Yeh, also acknowledged the program could be “performative” without the funds to back it up.
City staff have said a TOPA program that offers direct assistance to tenants would likely require about $50,000 in city subsidy for each housing unit preserved under the policy.
Eugene currently spends about $17,000 per unit to preserve existing affordable rental housing and about $8,000 per unit to build new affordable rental and shared-equity housing.
Councilor Alan Zelenka, who introduced the motion to advance the policy on Monday, compared the process to the rollout of previous city renter protections, which were grouped into phases and have been enacted over multiple years.
The first and second phases of renter protections, passed in 2022 and 2023, included caps on application screening fees, security deposit limits and relocation assistance.
“That was a big, huge thing,” Zelenka said. “It had financial implications as well, and what we did is we chunked it up into different pieces.”
Tenant advocates have been pushing Eugene to introduce a TOPA policy for more than a year.
Kevin Cronin, a board member of the Springfield-Eugene Tenant Association and the architect of the TOPA campaign in Eugene, said he was inspired to push for local TOPA legislation after hearing about elderly residents facing rent increases under new ownership at the downtown Eugene Hotel.
He said the council’s Monday decision is a step in the right direction.
“TOPA and preservation as a whole is a strategy to help contain the escalating housing costs for Oregonians, and so I applaud the City Council for taking steps towards that,” Cronin said.
Cronin acknowledged the many details the council still needs to hash out: how renters would form tenant associations, which properties might qualify and how tenant purchases would be financed.
Advocates have suggested ideas like raising the city’s 0.5% construction excise tax, increasing the $20 annual rental property registration cost for property owners, using fees paid by developers who tap the city’s Multi-Unit Property Tax Exemption policy and harnessing funds from the newly approved Eugene Clean Energy Fund.
“I want to make sure that we’re really thoughtful about how we spend the limited resources that the council has oversight over, and if we acquire more resources to do that too,” Cronin said.
Realtor Daniel Gandee, board president of the Rental Owners Association of Lane and Douglas Counties, said he would have “no problem” with legislation requiring advance notice to apartment tenants who may want to buy the building.
But for single-family homes, the policy could have a “drastic impact” to the real estate market.
“This is not an attack on landlords, but I also don’t believe this is an initiative that helps create more affordable housing,” he said.
Gandee said there isn’t evidence that funding a “full suite” tenant purchase proposal is an efficient use of dollars. He pointed to the differences in the housing markets of large cities that have enacted TOPA policies — like Washington, D.C., and San Francisco — from Eugene’s more stagnant midsized market.
“Is this more about politics and being progressive, or is this more about actual factual data that a city manager is telling you this is not a good road to go down?” he said.

