QuickTake:
Councilors, after initiating a meeting on the topic, unanimously agreed Eugene should develop a policy on how the city uses surveillance technologies. It also received a listing from staff on the types of systems now in use.
The city of Eugene aims to complete initial work on a policy defining and regulating surveillance technology by the end of the year.
Assistant City Manager Matt Rodrigues told city councilors Wednesday, June 17, that he hopes to deliver a “policy framework” for the citywide use of surveillance tools within the next six months.
The conversation came months after Eugene ended its controversial contract with Flock Safety, a company providing automated license-plate recognition cameras, after their use by the city police department sparked privacy concerns.
Wednesday’s meeting was scheduled after councilors had voted earlier to put the topic on their agenda. And at the meeting, the council unanimously agreed that Eugene should develop a citywide policy, with council input, that defines what surveillance technology is and mandates some level of oversight, like required reviews or assessments of privacy impacts.
“If something becomes controversial, comes in the public realm, it then becomes a policy issue that is of the purview of the City Council,” said Councilor Alan Zelenka. “The answer to the question of whether the City Council should establish a mass surveillance technology policy is clearly yes.”
Rodrigues and City Manager Jenny Haruyama warned councilors that policy development, particularly the process of getting public input, could take well over a year. So councilors expressed interest in a phased approach, starting with a policy framework by the year’s end.
“As we saw last year, the last thing we want is for the public and council to find out about new technology as it’s being installed,” said Councilor Lyndsie Leech. “We want that process to start earlier.”
Taking inventory
Ahead of Wednesday’s meeting, city staff completed Eugene’s first-ever “coordinated inventory effort” of its surveillance tools and identified six types of “camera-based security management technologies” now in use, Rodrigues told city councilors.
“Facial recognition is not used in any of the city’s current implementations of these technologies,” he said.
The six systems include:
- Security cameras
- Fixed security cameras:
- Purpose: Five city departments currently use fixed cameras, primarily for building and facility security, but also for traffic flow monitoring, traffic signal detection, and wastewater process monitoring.
- Quantity: The city uses about 700 of these cameras in 26 locations citywide
- Capabilities: Video-only. Uses like traffic operations are for real-time observation only, with no data recording.
- Data storage: “Typically stored” on city equipment
- Portable security cameras:
- Purpose: Same as fixed cameras, but they can be relocated. But Rodrigues pointed out that the cameras are “typically mounted in a way that requires significant effort to relocate them.” Public Works primarily uses these to monitor some parks facilities, and Eugene Police Department uses them as a “crime prevention and public safety tool” per department policy.
- Quantity: About six camera units in five locations citywide
- Capabilities: Video-only
- Data storage: “Typically stored” on city equipment
- Mobile security cameras:
- Purpose: Trailer-mounted systems that can be quickly deployed to locations experiencing “specific security concerns or operational needs,” by agencies like Public Works’ Parks and Open Spaces Division and EPD.
- Quantity: 10 camera units deployed “based on need”
- Capabilities: Video-only
- Data storage: “Typically stored” on city equipment
- Fixed security cameras:
- Camera security screening technology
- Purpose: City-owned security screening technology that combines video technology, metal detection, and machine learning algorithms to identify concealed weapons. Used at the Hult Center and City Hall Council Chambers.
- Quantity: Six city-owned units at two locations citywide, and one at the Cuthbert Amphitheater.
- Capabilities: Still images, no continuous video or audio
- Data storage: Stored in the cloud
- Drones, also known as small unmanned aerial systems
- Purpose: Public Works uses drones for infrastructure inspections, construction site monitoring, and assessments of parks, open spaces and waterways. EPD uses them for public safety and at times to assist Eugene Springfield Fire. The department’s use is limited and governed by state law, city policy and EPD policy. (“In most cases, for law enforcement purposes, EPD must obtain a warrant unless specific legal exceptions apply,” Rodrigues said.)
- Quantity: 27 drones owned by the city, deployed “based on need”
- Capabilities: Video-only
- Data storage: Stored in the cloud
- In-car video
- Purpose: Video systems installed in police patrol vehicles to document interactions between officers and members of the public and “provide objective evidence during investigations, assist with complaint resolution, support officer accountability, and improve transparency regarding police community interactions.”
- Quantity: Used in 125 EPD vehicles
- Capabilities: Video and audio
- Data storage: “Cloud-based” data storage
- Body-worn cameras
- Purpose: Cameras are deployed to all sworn EPD personnel. Similar to in-car video, but provide a “closer perspective on officer interactions” with the intent to “improve transparency, accountability, evidence collection, and public trust, while creating an objective record of interactions.”
- Quantity: 250 body-worn camera units worn by sworn personnel
- Capabilities: Video and audio
- Data storage: “Cloud-based” data storage
- Automated license-plate recognition, known as ALPR
- Fixed ALPR
- Purpose: License plate recognition systems “typically installed” on poles, on buildings, or at other fixed locations. The Planning and Development Department parking services team uses the systems at two downtown parking garages and at the Eugene Airport parking facilities to “support parking operations and facility management.”
- Quantity: The number of cameras was not disclosed, but the systems are located at three locations citywide
- Capabilities: Video-only
- Data storage: Data stored in the cloud
- Vehicle-based ALPR:
- Purpose: The Planning and Development Department parking services team also uses vehicle-mounted ALPR technology to “assist staff in identifying parking violations and unpaid parking citations,” though they are not connected to EPD or any “law-enforcement systems.”
- Quantity: Installed in about 14 parking service vehicles
- Capabilities: Video-only
- Data storage: Data stored in the cloud
- Fixed ALPR
Rodrigues said city staff are evaluating the “staffing and funding considerations” associated with the adoption of automated red-light and speed-safety cameras, which the city’s Vision Zero plan identifies as “proven tools” to reduce serious traffic crashes and fatalities.
“The team is trying to understand logistically how we would implement it if we chose to, how much it would cost, how that would work through Municipal Court, and how that would work through EPD,” he said. “We would be coming back to council to talk about that as a proposal.”
Peer cities and council feedback
Rodrigues pointed to Berkeley and San Jose, California, and Portland as examples of regional cities that have adopted city surveillance technology policies. Portland is the only city in Oregon with an established policy for surveillance technology.
Councilors broadly supported San Jose’s model, which Rodrigues said emphasizes the “privacy and civil liberties risks” posed by proposed new technology and requires the city’s privacy program to review tools based on level of risk, with oversight ranging from administrative reviews to public engagement.
“Staff ought to be really careful that something can’t blow up into a public issue, and ought to always lean towards the side of caution when involving the public in the conversation in advance,” Councilor Mike Clark said.
Have something to say?
Send us a Letter to the Editor. Read our guidelines for Letters to the Editor here.

