Editor’s note: This second story in “The Last Stand” series travels to Grandmother’s Grove, an old-growth stand on public BLM forestland in Lane County. It’s been protected for years. Now, as the BLM works on a new forest management plan, some have said the Trump administration’s call for more logging would pump more money into stretched county budgets. But under the current system, bigger timber sales haven’t meant bigger checks for Lane County.

Kate Gessert and her husband, Max, went looking for mushrooms and instead found an old-growth forest. 

The couple spent the day driving through the Coast Range patchwork of public and private land, stopping to forage in young forests between the clear-cuts. About 10 miles from home, they stopped and got out of the car, in awe of what loomed above them.

Huge Douglas firs rose with lichen-covered trunks, moss draped from thick branches of western hemlocks. They hiked from the roadway down into a fern-covered grove, bigleaf maples flaring gold.

“We were in this completely different world,” Gessert said. 

Sun shines through trees and moss in Grandmother’s Grove. Credit: Nick Rohlman / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

Then she noticed blue numbers spray-painted on the big trees, some wrapped in yellow tape. It quickly brought Gessert back to reality. This was a remnant, and it might not last. 

That was 22 years ago. Today, Gessert still holds her breath when she travels to visit the forest — until she sees the oldest, towering trees.

On a late October afternoon, soft rain fell as she steadied herself with a cork-topped trekking pole. She leaned against a sapling and looked up.

“There they are,” she said. “The grandmothers.” 

Kate Gessert — with her husband, Max — points out some of the oldest trees in Grandmother’s Grove, during an October visit to the protected old-growth stand in Lane County. Gessert calls them “the grandmothers,” and she played a big part in advocating for their protection status. Credit: Ashli Blow / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

Grandmother’s Grove is a 60-acre public forest in Lane County designated as an “Area of Critical Environmental Concern,” meaning the Bureau of Land Management put it off-limits to scheduled commercial logging — at least for now.

It’s among the 2.5 million acres BLM oversees in western Oregon.

How the agency manages this land, what it cuts and what it conserves, is set by rulebooks called resource management plans. For 1.3 million of those acres, including the BLM forests around Eugene and Springfield, that rulebook is the Northwestern Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan.

For additional policy details, read Lookout Eugene-Springfield’s explainer of BLM’s Northwestern and Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan.

That plan is up for revision, and the agency is preparing to release a draft for public comment in the coming weeks, with an emphasis on returning to “historically higher” harvests of the 1970s and 1980s.

Old trees in Grandmother’s Grove (center) tower over younger forests and tree farms. Nick Rohlman / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

“The history of it is that everything got chopped up into pieces,” Gessert said of the Coast Range. “Then you take those little pieces, and you start chopping them up, too. Then you just get these little, tiny slivers left.”

She is worried about whether those slivers, the ones tucked away for conservation, will survive.

Some federal and local leaders frame off-limit forests as holding back the potential for logging dollars to help county budgets.

But federal data and policy analysis show a more complicated picture. Even at its peak in the 1970s and 1980s, BLM money was rarely steady, and since 2000, it has covered only a fraction of what counties book as timber dollars. And in recent years, as BLM’s timber receipts got bigger, many counties, including Lane, haven’t seen more money from it.

Hanging in the balance are forests like Grandmother’s Grove.

The money trees 

For thousands of years, old Douglas firs anchored the Coast Range in what are now Lane and Douglas counties, part of a temperate rainforest belt stretching from Alaska to Northern California. Fog lofted, rain fell, fire burned in a shifting mosaic of old and young trees.

Some of that fire was set by Indigenous people who tended these forests in their understory for food, game and basketry materials.

White settlers moving West saw the big firs as something else: money trees.

And so, the U.S. government turned the land into a checkerboard.

In the mid-1800s, Congress granted land in alternating squares to a rail line between Portland and San Francisco, on the condition that it sell some of those squares to homesteaders in small parcels. But the Oregon and California Railroad Co. sold the land in large chunks for profit in a legacy of corruption.

Congress took back the unsold land and passed the Oregon and California Revested Railroad Lands Act of 1937, known as the O&C Act.

The law gave the 18 counties containing O&C lands a way to get paid for property they couldn’t tax, because it was owned by the federal government. Revenue from timber sales would substitute for property taxes and fund public services.

How timber payments worked last century:

  • Federal foresters, eventually through BLM, marked a stand and estimated its volume in board feet and set a price. The law required a minimum volume to be sold each year. 
  • Timber companies bid on stands at auction, then cut the trees and hauled the logs to mills.
  • Companies paid the federal government in installments as they cut. That money is called “timber receipts.”
  • Counties got a share of the receipts, called “timber payments.” Half of those receipts went to 18 O&C counties, each receiving their payment through a fixed percentage: 15.27% for Lane County; 25.05% for Douglas County. The other half went to the federal government.
  • Because receipts came in as trees were cut, not when the sale was made, a county’s payment could arrive years after the auction. 

The system thrived during post-World War II housing development and got a boost in the 1960s when BLM doubled its harvest cap, from 500 million board feet annually to 1 billion board feet.

Old-growth timber near Yachats in 1923, during the era when Oregon’s coastal forests were seen as “money trees.” Credit: Lincoln County Historical Society Archive, Oregon State University

In 1970, a federal commission — formed to advise Congress on governing public lands — warned of a boom-and-bust cycle in a report. The report firmly supported timber production but found the revenue-sharing model problematic.

Some years the model overpaid counties. Other years, it shorted them. And, the report said, it created pressure to cut timber in ways that could “be in conflict with good conservation-management practices.”

The warnings came to pass in the 1980s, when a national recession hit, and timber payments plunged. Then in the 1990s, the system Congress designed broke for good.

The landmark Northwest Forest Plan required the U.S. Forest Service and the BLM to set aside old forests from logging and conserve them as habitat for the northern spotted owl. The harvest caps came back down.

To fill the gap, Congress began sending counties, including Lane County, “safety net” payments in 1993. This meant “timber payments” were no longer funded only by timber.

The help was meant to be temporary, as counties found other revenue streams. Instead, Congress recommitted to support in 2000 with the Secure Rural Schools Act, covering revenue from both BLM and national forest service land. National forest, which make up 48% of lands in Lane County are managed similarly to, but separate, from BLM lands, which make up about 10% of the county.

‘Timber payments’

The O&C timber payments sent to western Oregon counties no longer work the way they were first designed, with the U.S. treasury sending money to counties when timber receipts are low.

How timber payments work this century:

  • Congress guarantees counties a fixed amount of money, based on what they once received from timber payments. 
  • The guarantee was meant to be temporary, so the amount shrinks over time.
  • Timber receipts, money from O&C timber sales, still go into the payments. Companies still pay as the trees are cut.
  • In years when timber receipts are weak, the U.S. Treasury makes up the difference between the receipts and the guarantee.
  • In years when timber receipts are strong, excess money is returned to the U.S. Treasury. 

For the first 14 years of the 2000s, the U.S. Treasury sent millions of dollars annually to O&C counties. Then, timber receipts bounced back in 2016, when BLM adopted new plans for western Oregon forests, replacing direction from the Northwest Forest Plan. Also that year, Secure Rural Schools lapsed, although the program was later revived by Congress.

Counties that opt into Secure Rural Schools get a fixed amount no matter how much timber sells.

This is why some counties, including Coos and Columbia, have opted out of the Secure Rural Schools program. Lane County hasn’t, because doing so could affect its national forest payments under the same law, which fund other parts of the county budget, according to local officials.

Christine Moody, a budget and financial planning manager, has worked for Lane County over the past 25 years, starting the year Secure Rural Schools went into effect. She’s watched the spreadsheets fluctuate, trying to maximize federal dollars ever since.

She still titles a budget line item “O&C Timber Sales.” In the 2025-26 fiscal year, Lane County booked nearly $3.5 million there, about 3% of its general fund.

“The funds are critical to providing services to the community,” Moody said. “Even the cost of one deputy is going to be a benefit to the community. … It’s very important for public safety, in particular, because public safety spends most of the discretionary general fund.”

Asked why the account is still called “O&C Timber Sales” when it holds a mix of funding sources, she said, “I just never changed it.”

From left: Lane County Commissioners Pat Farr, David Loveall, Ryan Ceniga and Heather Buch at a board meeting in 2025. Credit: Isaac Wasserman / Lookout Eugene-Springfield / Catchlight / RFA

That nuance of what’s included in the O&C timber payments rarely comes up in public, including at meetings of the Lane County Board of Commissioners. 

“These lands were designated for the good and the economic viability of every county,” said Commissioner David Loveall during a meeting March 17, when commissioners discussed whether the county should become a cooperating agency with BLM as it revises the Northwestern Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan.

The board agreed unanimously that Lane County needed a voice in the federal process. It split over whose voice that should be.

Who is in the best position to advocate for Lane County? Commissioner Heather Buch

The debate centered on the Association of O&C Counties, called the AOCC, a group that lobbies for federal timber revenues. Lane County is a member of the association and pays $80,000 a year for the group’s lobbying and legal fees.

Commissioners Loveall, Pat Farr and Ryan Ceniga voted to designate the association to represent Lane County as BLM updates its resource management plan. Commissioners Laurie Trieger and Heather Buch voted against.

“If we’re going to be a participating entity, who is in the best position to advocate for Lane County to be that representative? I argue that that would be Lane County,” Buch said. “If we give it to an outside entity such as AOCC, I wonder if their priorities and what they send and actually communicate with BLM is going to be the same as what is in the best interests of Lane County.”

Buch also questioned the group’s transparency. She told the board she has asked for years to see the group’s meeting minutes and that she doesn’t feel informed about its actions. 

The Association of O&C Counties did not respond to Lookout Eugene-Springfield’s repeated requests for comment, nor did its president, Douglas County Commissioner Tim Freeman. A Douglas County spokesperson declined an interview about its O&C payments.

‘Part of life’ 

The BLM set a June deadline to release a draft environmental impact statement — a legally required analysis — on its “preliminary alternative” to increase timber production on its lands. June came and went.

Sarah Bennett, a spokesperson for BLM Oregon/Washington, said the draft is coming but gave no date. 

“We didn’t want to rush it,” Bennett said, adding the agency is carefully considering the public comment received in February, when it shared preliminary information through a “notice of intent.”

That notice states in part: 

BLM has developed a preliminary alternative that would meet the purpose of providing an increase in timber harvest levels of production to align with historically higher levels of volume on BLM-administered public lands in the decision area. The preliminary alternative would manage BLM-administered lands to provide a sustained yield of timber production consistent with the maximum productive capacity of the lands.

The BLM’s Northwestern Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan is divided into five main management zones. Its Harvest Land Base, an allocation for timber, makes up about 20%. “Late Successional Reserves,” an allocation for spotted owl habitat, makes up 46%.

“District Reserves” include the Areas of Critical Environmental Concerns, which are reserved for conservation and cultural values. Bennett said these Areas of Critical Environmental Concerns make up 2% to 4% of the agency’s planning and have not been analyzed for commercial timber harvest.

However, she could not confirm the areas would be ruled out from potential reallocation. 
Meanwhile, the Department of the Interior this month proposed new rules that would give the BLM more flexibility in how it designates and sizes Areas of Critical Environmental Concern.

“Our draft plan, that’ll lay out our first range of proposed actions,” she said, pointing to House Bill 1, the GOP-supported tax and spending bill and executive orders signed by President Donald Trump in 2025. “We think there’s more timber that could be harvested.” 

Grandmother’s Grove (right) stands between private and other O&C lands. Credit: Nick Rohlman / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

The BLM’s current plan describes Grandmother’s Grove as a rare patch of mature and older forest, stands that are typically 80 to more than 200 years old. It sets the grove aside from commercial logging so it can develop through natural, ecological processes.

The agency decided at one time that the grove was worth preserving, Gessert said, and the forest “didn’t suddenly change overnight because the government’s priorities changed.”

Since she first visited in 2004, Gessert has watched nearby forest practices take a toll on the grandmothers. The original grandmothers she saw died in recent years. She noticed their rapid decline around 2019, after roadside equipment cleared the brush and young trees along Wolf Creek Road.

Two old Douglas firs, now snags, stand in Grandmother’s Grove. Credit: Ashli Blow / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

She turned to academic papers that described this as the “edge effect.” That’s when trees get more sunlight and wind — becoming warmer and drier — than trees inside a larger forest.

But the trees are taking on new purposes. Hollowing trunks serve as nesting places for birds. Fallen branches return nutrients to the forest floor as they decompose. 

Other old trees surround them. Some could become grandmothers themselves, the dominating trees of this forest — but only if they get the chance.

Gessert, a retired educator, understands budget strains, but believes there are other values to standing forests like this grove: ecological richness and connection to nature.

It’s why she brought her students there for years.

They were adults from Lane Community College taking English as a second language, and on trip days entire families would join Gessert to see the grandmothers.

At her home in Crow, Gessert opened her laptop — letters worn off the keys from writing and researching — to look at her notes. She wrote down what her students told her when they were out together. 

“This student burst out, almost shouting,” Gessert recalled, turning to read the account. “‘It’s all connected, all of it. The dead trees on the ground, the dead trees standing up, the live trees, all the little plants. They’re all part of life.'” 

Kate Gessert holds a photo from a field trip to Grandmother’s Grove, showing children and parents joining hands in a ring around one of the original “grandmothers.” Credit: Ashli Blow / Lookout-Eugene Springfield

About ‘The Last Stand’

Lookout’s Environment & Public Health Correspondent Ashli Blow is reporting a living journalism series examining old-growth stands in Douglas and Lane counties through the perspectives of groups with competing, deeply rooted views on the future of Oregon’s forests: industry and contractors, conservationists and neighbors, and the BLM officials who decide how these lands are managed.

Want to connect with Ashli Blow about The Last Stand? Reach out via email at ashli@lookoutlocal.com 

Help Lookout reporters take on our community’s biggest issues

This evolving series and our in-depth reporting on Lane County’s environmental issues is made possible by the support of Lookout’s members, who fund what is now the second-largest local newsroom in Oregon. Join Lookout today to contribute to future reporting, projects and investigations.

Ashli Blow brings 12 years of experience in journalism and science writing, focusing on the intersection of issues that impact everyone connected to the land — whether private or public, developed or forested.