QuickTake:
Public land managers and an industry group representing timber companies are asking a federal appeals court to overturn a ruling that vacated the Blue and Gold logging project southwest of Eugene.
Editor’s Note: This article updates the status of a court case covered in the first installment of “The Last Stand,” a developing series about Bureau of Land Management forests around Eugene and Roseburg, as the Trump administration pushes to expand timber production in western Oregon. Stakes are high for local economies that depend on timber — and for old-growth forests that may never return.
The Bureau of Land Management has appealed a federal judge’s ruling that halted its Blue and Gold Harvest Plan, a nearly 3,400-acre logging project about 60 miles southwest of Eugene.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals opened two cases Sept. 23: one for BLM’s appeal and the other for a separate, but related, appeal by two groups who want logging to resume.
The filings come more than four months after the U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai ruled in favor of the plaintiffs: Cascadia Wildlands, Oregon Wild and Umpqua Watersheds.
The groups sued BLM in September 2024, accusing BLM for misrepresenting old-growth stands as being younger than they really were. This facilitated illegal cutting, they argued.
In early May, a Cascadia Wildlands organizer and volunteers reported finding freshly cut stumps they said were larger than what BLM’s own plan allowed. Plaintiffs filed a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction to stop logging. A couple of days later, Kasubhai ruled BLM violated two federal laws.
The Federal Land Policy and Management Act: A law that legally binds BLM to its own guidance in Resource Management Plans, such as protecting trees 40 inches or wider or trees about 175 years or older. Kasubhai ruled BLM failed to show it was complying with that rule.
The National Environmental Policy Act: A law that requires agencies to conduct detailed study and disclose a project’s environmental impact before approving it, should the impact be significant. Kasubhai ruled BLM didn’t adequately explain why it considered the project’s effect on old-growth insignificant.
In his May ruling, Kasubhai’s order to vacate the entire Blue and Gold project meant the agency would need to redo its environmental review to move forward.
In the following weeks, the BLM and groups including the American Forest Resource Council, which joined the case on the agency’s side, filed motions asking Kasubhai to reconsider.
The council is an industry group that represents timber companies, including Springfield-based Rosboro, which had bought two of the timber sales in the project, according to a court declaration filed by a company executive.
Through several court declarations, BLM and timber stakeholders underscored another law at play, the O&C Act, that they interpret as a legal obligation to harvest timber on public lands.
The O&C Act: A law specific to the Blue and Gold project due to the project’s location on former Oregon and California Railroad land, deals with land that had been granted by the federal government to the railroad. The government later reclaimed the land after the railroad abused the deal. The resulting 1937 law placed the land under BLM management, with a mandate that prioritizes timber production to this day.
In July, Kasubhai denied the requests to reconsider and closed the case, citing economic harms were not enough to change his ruling.
BLM filed its notice of appeal Sept. 18 in U.S. District Court. The American Forest Resource Council and the Association of O&C Counties — a group that represents 18 counties, including Lane County, and lobbies for timber harvests that help fund county budgets — filed their appeal the same day.
Opening briefs laying out their arguments are due Nov. 2.
Asked about the appeal in an email Monday, BLM declined to provide additional comment to Lookout Eugene-Springfield.
American Forest Resource Council spokesperson Nick Smith sent the following statement in an email:
“AFRC and the Association of O&C Counties have appealed the district court decision vacating the Blue and Gold Project, which was carefully designed to support forest health, local timber supply, family-wage jobs, and county revenues in western Oregon.
In his statement, Smith also pointed to a 9th Circuit decision this month that overturned a ruling by Kasubhai in a separate case regarding a broader BLM logging plan involving 13,000 acres west of Eugene. The decision does not set binding precedent for other cases, according to court records.
“(The Ninth Circuit’s recent reversal) reinforces our view that the BLM deserves appropriate deference when it follows the National Environmental Policy Act and makes reasonable forest management decisions. We look forward to making that case on appeal,” Smith said.
Oregon Wild’s senior staff attorney John Persell sent the following statement in an email:
“The district court’s decision is clear: based on the agency’s own record, the BLM withheld information and misrepresented conditions in these forests to the public, and logging them will result in severe impacts to old growth,” Persell said. “Neither the BLM nor the logging industry can obscure those facts.”
Cascadia Wildlands did not have a comment Monday.

