QuickTake:

Sabrina Gordon moved to dismiss the case and drop all payment requests when Eugene School District 4J agreed to drop its payment requests. Gordon’s attorney did not state reasoning for dismissing the case, but discovery documents revealed intensifying requests for information and denials between both parties.

Former teacher’s union president Sabrina Gordon has dropped her lawsuit against Eugene School District 4J, according to court documents.

Gordon filed a lawsuit against the district in November 2025, alleging the district failed to properly address rumors about her having a sexual relationship with former Superintendent Andy Dey. Gordon has said the rumors were false, and she accused the district of sexual harassment, among other claims.

The lawsuit included previously unknown details of 4J’s 2023-24 school year, including circumstances around Dey’s exit from the district, Gordon’s conflict with former union Vice President Imelda Rodriguez De la Cruz and rumors that spread about Gordon and Dey’s relationship.

Court documents did not reveal the reason behind Gordon and 4J’s mutual agreements to dismiss the case and drop all requests for attorney fees or monetary awards, but filings from the month leading up to the Sept. 17 dismissal (with prejudice, meaning the lawsuit cannot be refiled) revealed intensifying records requests and refusals by both parties during discovery.

Gordon’s attorney, Diane Sykes, wanted the district to release personnel documents for De la Cruz, and Bob Gray, a former 4J employee, who allegedly also spread rumors about Gordon and Dey’s relationship. Sykes also requested De la Cruz’s complaints against Dey, the district’s investigation into Dey, a settlement agreement between the district and De la Cruz and a 10-year history of employee sexual harassment complaints in the district, among other records.

The attorneys representing 4J wanted Gordon to hand over 10 years of tax returns, unredacted medical, counseling records and calendars, and text communications between Gordon and Dey, which Gordon admitted to deleting in April 2024, after rumors about a sexual relationship between them started. District attorneys argued that could be grounds for unlawful destruction of evidence.

Both sides had also filed motions requesting attorney fees for disputes during discovery.

According to email records reviewed by Lookout Eugene-Springfield, attorneys representing the two parties spoke by telephone before jointly moving to dismiss the case. Sykes reportedly said on the phone call that Gordon was willing to dismiss the case with prejudice and drop all requests for payment if the district also dropped all requests for payment. This included dropping the rights to attorney fees previously granted to Sykes by Lane County Circuit Court Judge Charles Zennaché to fight the district’s motion to have the case dismissed earlier this year. Zennaché signed the dismissal the two sides agreed to on Sept. 22.

“The district is satisfied with the outcome, and always maintained that dismissal was the correct response,” said Kelly McIver, Eugene School District 4J director of communications.

Lilly is a graduate of Indiana University and has worked as a journalist at the Indianapolis Star and in Burlington, Vermont, as well as working as a foreign language teacher in France. She covers education and children's issues for Lookout Eugene-Springfield.