QuickTake:

According to the complaint, the University of Oregon rescinded a job offer after a background check turned up a misdemeanor related to protest against the war in Gaza.

A Multnomah County resident filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the University of Oregon, alleging officials revoked their job offer for protesting against the war in Gaza.

The complaint, filed Thursday, Nov. 19, in U.S. District Court in Eugene, claims that UO rescinded a job offer extended to Nic Francisco-Kaho’onei after a background check turned up a misdemeanor conviction related to protesting against the war in Gaza. The lawsuit alleges the university violated Francisco-Kaho’onei’s rights to free speech and equal protection.

The university didn’t immediately return a request for comment. 

Francisco-Kaho’onei, who uses they/them pronouns, applied in August 2024 to become program director of UO’s Women’s Center under the Office of the Dean of Students, according to the complaint. The center is a campus space that hosts gender and sexuality-related events and provides student resources like lactation rooms and menstruation products.

UO offered Francisco-Kaho’onei the job in November 2024, which they accepted, the complaint states. 

The offer was contingent on a background check, which subsequently flagged Francisco-Kaho’onei’s misdemeanor arrest for disorderly conduct in April 2024, according to the complaint. 

Francisco-Kaho’onei said in the complaint the misdemeanor charge “was related to their exercise of constitutionally protected free speech and protest,” and that they were contesting the charge with legal representation from the Civil Liberties Defense Center.

Lane County Circuit Court records show that Francisco-Kaho’onei was charged with second-degree disorderly conduct after blocking traffic on Interstate 5 during a pro-Palestine protest in April 2024. They were convicted of the charge Nov. 27, 2024, after switching their plea from not guilty to guilty. Francisco-Kaho’onei was ordered to pay a $50 fine and complete 40 hours of community service. 

Meanwhile, UO announced Francisco-Kaho’onei’s hiring to staff members. But on Dec. 4, UO told Francisco-Kaho’onei the university was rescinding the job offer because “the charges that turned up on the background check had not been adjudicated, and UO did not want to wait for that to happen,” the complaint reads. 

In response, Francisco-Kaho’onei told UO the “low-level charges” were related to “protest actions,” and the charges were adjudicated the month before, according to the complaint. 

Francisco-Kaho’onei wrote a letter to UO Dec. 9, requesting the university reconsider the decision and attached a court judgment and a sentencing statement that documented the case had been adjudicated, the complaint states. 

In the letter, Francisco-Kaho’onei wrote they were involved in “an act of civil disobedience protest related to the ongoing genocide in Gaza” that was grounded in their commitment to social justice and human rights. Francisco-Kaho’onei went on to argue in the letter that their criminal history was irrelevant to their ability to perform duties for the UO job. 

Yet on Dec. 19, 2024, UO told Francisco-Kaho’onei the university was rescinding the job offer because the “very recent conviction is relevant to the Program Director position,” according to the complaint. 

“The communication did not explain or elaborate as to how the misdemeanor conviction related to protesting an ongoing genocide was relevant to the Program Director position,” the complaint states.

Francisco-Kaho’onei appealed the revocation, but UO upheld its decision, the complaint states. 

“Upon information and belief, UO rescinded Dr. Francisco-Kaho’onei’s job offer because they engaged in activity protected by the First Amendment,” the complaint alleges. 

Francisco-Kaho’onei is seeking a jury trial and damages for lost wages and benefits, harm to their career and emotional distress, along with attorney fees and a court declaration that the defendants violated their First Amendment rights.

Mark Schmelz, UO vice president and chief human resources officer, Angela Lauer Chong, vice president of student life, and Jimmy Howard, associate vice president for student life and dean of students, are also named as defendants. 

Schmelz will leave Oregon for a new job with Cornell University in January.

A Human Resources FAQ on UO’s website states that a job applicant’s criminal conviction will not result in an automatic disqualification from hiring. The university also considers factors like the nature and gravity of the offense, time since conviction and the offense’s “degree of relevance to the position for which the candidate is being considered,” according to the website. 

“Not all criminal convictions are considered to be job-related, and decisions about criminal convictions and employment are made on a case-by-case basis,” the website reads.

Francisco-Kaho’onei was working as director of Portland State University’s Women’s Resource Center when they applied for the UO job. 

In April 2025 — well after UO allegedly rescinded its job offer — Francisco-Kaho’onei was terminated from their job at PSU with no explanation, the Portland Mercury reported. 

Francisco-Kaho’onei argued their firing was due to their public support of Palestine and student activism, and has since filed a tort claim against the university.

“I filed this lawsuit to hold UO accountable for rescinding my job offer due to my political activity, which feels like selective enforcement,” Francisco Kaho’onei said in a statement to Lookout Eugene-Springfield. “It is especially important in this moment, just as it was in 2024, to speak out against the ongoing genocide in Gaza, to fully exercise our First Amendment rights, and to seek accountability from government institutions when they violate those rights.”

Grace Chinowsky graduated from The George Washington University with a degree in journalism. She served as editor-in-chief of the university’s independent student newspaper, The GW Hatchet, and interned at CNN and MSNBC. Grace covers Eugene’s city government and the University of Oregon.