QuickTake:
The utility requested an “actionable” assessment from an emergency management consulting firm following the ice storm and has been taking steps the past two years to shore up its response to a large emergency, including improved communications and training.
About 75% of Springfield Utility Board customers lost power at some point during the January 2024 ice storm.
For five days starting Jan. 13, two bouts of freezing rain blanketed Lane County in a thick layer of ice and brought down trees and power poles. The storm hit Springfield especially hard. Officials said it affected around 20,000 trees, damaged 241 homes and destroyed 80 utility poles.
Some residents were without power for two weeks, leading to frustration and anger. Three weeks after the ice started to thaw, SUB held a listening session to hear from community members about the utility’s storm response. It also collected feedback through an online survey and conducted internal as well as external after-action reports.

That feedback formed the basis of a lengthy to-do list, and SUB has been working on it for the past two years. The aim is to better position it to respond to a similar storm. The document lists about 70 actions in several categories, including emergency operations training, customer communications and critical facilities backup.
Springfield Utility Board General Manager Jeff Nelson told Lookout Eugene-Springfield he thinks the utility has come a long way, with more steps to come.
“I do think, though, that the next time there’s an event of that magnitude, that the community is going to see a different level of response from SUB, and it’s going to be a much better response, and that’s what the community deserves,” Nelson said.
The general manager said the utility followed the Federal Emergency Management Agency framework for an internal after-action review following the ice storm.
“I said, ‘I want it all,’” Nelson said. “I want it raw. I want to know what the concerns were, what we did well, what we didn’t, and be transparent about it.”
The board paid Hagerty Consulting, an emergency management consulting firm with experience working with utility clients, $65,350 for a report to help them prepare for and respond to disasters.
“I said, ‘We want an authentic, transparent and actionable report,’” Nelson said. “If we didn’t have a transparent process, we didn’t have an actionable process, if we didn’t have a comprehensive process, the community is just not being served.”
Customer communication
SUB’s communications during the storm did not meet customers’ needs, according to Hagerty. The utility, in its internal report, stated it “must do a better job at communicating information to the public.”
The Hagerty report states SUB’s external communications were overly reliant on social media and internet access, which were not accessible to all customers due to power outages. It says SUB’s emergency plans did not provide guidance on how to develop, approve and distribute public messages or an ideal cadence, leading to frustration from customers who wanted more updates.
Changes made by SUB to address communications include:
- Online outage map to deploy during a widespread power outage event
- Online form for customers to report outages
- Text messages to alert customers during an emergency
- Boil water notice map
SUB spokesperson Meredith Clark said SUB doesn’t have smart meters, so the utility has to get outage information directly from its electric service crews. Customer reporting is another way for the utility to gather information on outages during a large event.
“So that just in general helps people understand where they are in the giant world of the event,” Clark told Lookout, adding that the systems have been tested but not deployed, as there has not been a big-enough outage event.
The utility is also beefing up its internal staff to better handle communication needs.
Clark said additional personnel completed media training so technicians who are subject-matter experts feel more comfortable sharing information with reporters.
“All of us wanted to make sure that people felt comfortable and understood what reporters need, because [they] are a conduit to talking to customers,” she said. “And again, it’s just one of those ways where we can make communicating with our customers more effective and more efficient.”
SUB also added a third person to its communications team to build capacity. It also embedded a communications staff person in the field to capture real‑time information.
“We weren’t as well-placed to do that during the ice storm, and I think that people really wanted to have somebody with the crews taking photos, taking videos, saying ‘This is what we’re working on,’ so people could understand it,” Clark said.
She said SUB has protocols in place for distribution of signs as needed when cell towers and internet providers are down.

Expectation setting and training
Another Hagerty observation was the lack of consensus between SUB and the city about who was responsible for what following the event.
“Interviews with both SUB and the city showed a mutual misunderstanding regarding who was responsible for elements of response and restoration,” the Hagerty report states. “For instance, citizens’ unmet needs – or humanitarian elements of incident response – are typically the responsibility of government entities, whereas restoring power is typically the responsibility of the utility. … SUB and the city indicated that each party assumed the other would be responsible for meeting citizens’ unmet needs.”
According to the Oregon Department of Emergency Management, the utility is responsible for restoring water and electricity during an emergency, Nelson said. Other emergency support functions, such as mass care, are not.
“During the ice storm, there was a real demand for humanitarian response, and that’s mass care, and that’s a different emergency support function than we have the capacity, planning or even ability to implement and make a request,” he said.
Nevertheless, SUB tried to respond to the community’s needs; meter readers were asked to knock on doors to “provide information, provide water and try to see what we can do to fill that gap that we saw that the community had in the moment,” Nelson said

After the storm, SUB was asked why the National Guard wasn’t activated, something the utility has no authority to do.
“The community, understandably, was under a lot of stress, and I think that there were a lot of requests from SUB for SUB to do functions … outside of our responsibility,” he said. “And I think there’s a better understanding now amongst different agencies about staying in our lanes, planning for our lanes, preparing for our lanes, responding within our lanes, because if we go outside our lanes, even though it’s well intentioned, it just can create some confusion.”
A community resource center opened Jan. 20 at Springfield City Hall, providing residents with food boxes and firewood.
Some changes that made to better address future emergencies include:
- Developing a geographic app — Springfield Emergency Response Application (SERA) — to track incidents, provide real-time updates and manage wellness checks and resource distribution
- Having city staff complete incident command system training (SUB staff also completed that training)
- Establishing an emergency-activated AM radio station
Last year, SUB and the city did a tabletop exercise at the Justice Center on a fictional emergency event, a report recommendation.
“We’re all able to experience in that fictional tabletop just how communication occurs and who’s responsible for what,” Nelson said.

The Hagerty report stated that SUB’s internal coordination and communication were inadequate for the scale of the storm response.
Clark said the utility worked to improve internal communications by requiring all staff to complete Federal Emergency Management Training and making it part of new-employee training.
“People look at, what’s the silver bullet?” Clark said. “What’s the next, new, big technology? And really what it is for us, I think, is that everyday communication.”
To handle anticipated higher call volumes, SUB also partnered with an external regional call center to support during a large outage.
Infrastructure
“The initial freezing rain created dangerous road conditions and led to some outages in SUB’s service area,” the Hagerty report states. “Once the weather subsided, SUB began the power restoration process only to have most of their work undone by a second wave of freezing rain.”
The weather, compounded by cold load pickup, which is a high demand for power when re-energizing a circuit after a long outage, “caused extensive damage to SUB’s assets.”
According to SUB, the utility’s crews repaired or replaced nearly 50,000 feet of electrical wire following the storm.

In areas where poles needed to be replaced, SUB upgraded the infrastructure to a “more current engineering standard compared to maybe when they’ve been installed,” Nelson said.
Nelson said the utility is following up on grant requests to bury portions of SUB power lines.
“But those opportunities may be limited,” he said.
SUB does place electrical lines for new developments underground.
The utility trims trees around power lines and makes a full circuit of the trees in its jurisdiction every four years, Nelson said. SUB doesn’t manage trees on private property or in the city’s right of way.
“Even though we were still trimming, we just had trees that were outside that tree trimming vicinity that were falling into our facilities or falling into other trees that were falling into our facilities,” Nelson said.

He said the utility is exploring options to relocate electrical transformers from residential backyards to the front of the property, making them easier to access during an emergency. Some of that work has already been done in east Springfield.
SUB applied for grants for backup generators to serve three critical facilities: the electric service center, water service center and Willamette Treatment Plant. The electric service center has a backup generator, with the other two to follow, to ensure those facilities are functional during an emergency.
Other critical facilities, such as SUB’s main office, have backup power so customers can contact the utility during an outage. Nelson said SUB also wants to integrate renewable power into existing backup generation to extend the amount of time a generator can be used.
A defining moment for the community
Nelson said SUB is better prepared to respond to an emergency such as the 2024 ice storm.
“I think that this particular event was a defining moment for the entire community,” he said. “I think that the identified areas that we needed to improve on, those were identified in the after-action report. We took a lot of feedback and distilled that into actionable items, and we’re further along as a utility for utility restoration today than we were before the ice storm.”
He also thinks the community is more prepared.
“We’ve seen a lot of folks lean into the opportunity and say, ‘Hey, I need a backup generator,’” Nelson said.
After the storm, SUB started a pilot program for 0% loans for portable generators and transfer switches. Clark said the program was limited to 50 participants, and staff are evaluating the pilot results and will make a recommendation on the program once the analysis is complete.
When asked what he wants to do differently in the event of another emergency like this one, Nelson said he would want to communicate with customers sooner about what’s happening, what SUB’s responsibility is and what the utility is doing about it.
“I think setting up clear expectations and letting customers know earlier on what we’re doing about that particular situation could have been a more helpful exercise during the ice storm, and would be something that would be more helpful the next time,” he said.
Have something to say?
Send us a Letter to the Editor. Read our guidelines for Letters to the Editor here.


