QuickTake:

The Trump administration filed a proposal to rescind the national Roadless Rule, which has protected 8,000 acres around Hardesty Mountain from road construction since 2001. The change has industry and environmentalists divided over the future of local forests.

1:15 p.m.: Updated to include reaction from industry and environmental groups.

The U.S. Forest Service has filed a proposal to rescind the national Roadless Rule, according to an announcement from the U.S. Department of Agriculture on Tuesday, Aug. 18.

Contested since its 2001 inception, the Roadless Rule bars road construction on nearly 45 million acres of national forest land. That includes about 2 million acres in Oregon, 8,000 of which are in Lane County, surrounding Hardesty Mountain in the Willamette National Forest — about 25 miles from downtown Eugene.

A map of Willamette National Forest shows roadless areas in brown and orange shades. Credit: USFS
A map of Siuslaw National Forest shows roadless areas in brown and orange shades. Credit: USFS

Last year, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins announced plans to repeal the rule, opening it up for public comment. An analysis of those comments by the Center for Western Priorities found 99.2% of submissions to the Federal Register supported keeping the rule in place.

A Tuesday press release citing Rollins said that moving forward with the repeal aligns with President Donald Trump’s executive orders aimed at accelerating logging on public lands. The release also said rescission does not mandate timber cutting or road construction.

“Today, we filed a proposal to restore authority to local forest managers who know the land best, removing the barriers that have kept them from doing the work the land demands,” Rollins said.  

Rollins and the release use terms like “forest health” and “productivity,” which the administration, industry and environmental groups define in different — sometimes conflicting — ways.

For example, to the Trump administration, “forest health” means, in part, thinning dense tree stands to reduce wildfire fuel loads. To many environmentalists, the same term also means preserving old-growth stands and natural fire cycles that roads and logging can disrupt.

In its statement supporting the proposal, the American Forest Resource Council, which represents timber interest nationwide including companies in Eugene and Springfield, invoked the term “conservation” in reference to their view of forest management.

“The Forest Service is right to take a hard look at a policy that was written for forest conditions that looked very different 25 years ago,” council President Travis Joseph said, in part, in a written statement. “Rescinding the Roadless Rule gives local forest professionals greater flexibility to use science and their expertise to decide what these landscapes need instead of having those decisions dictated by a nationwide rule.”

Eugene-based conservation groups — including Oregon Wild, Cascadia Wildlands and Firefighters United for Safety Ethics and Ecology — held several public events advocating to keep the rule in place, also pushing for science-based approaches. 

Tuesday, in response to the announcement, those conservation groups alongside eight others in Oregon sent a letter to Rollins asking for a longer public comment period this round, given that a draft environmental impact statement, known as a DEIS, is up for discussion. These impact statements are meant to analyze how development could affect land, water, wildlife and communities.

“The Forest Service’s allowance of only 30 days for public comment is woefully inadequate for this purpose,” the letter read, in part. “Meaningful engagement with the DEIS and Proposed Rule requires analysis of detailed factual and scientific information that cannot reasonably be completed, compiled, and presented to the agency in only 30 days.”

More information on the proposal will be available Wednesday, with public comment opening shortly after on regulations.gov. Public comment will close at midnight Sept. 21.

Ashli Blow brings 12 years of experience in journalism and science writing, focusing on the intersection of issues that impact everyone connected to the land — whether private or public, developed or forested.